The initial reasoning doesn’t allow me to debar any version of this tragic event, so I can’t debar also the option of an accident and I can’t rule out the assassination, a planned action -as the media-. Media seem to target only the version of the accident, and the so-called warning against drawing hasty conclusions. So what? Don’t even put the question of whether the disaster couldn’t be planned the action? Maybe the question bother somebody? It offends someone? If not, it certainly offends common sense. But sense don’t afraid to question and as someone pointed out rightly, there are no stupid questions, may be only stupid answers. In this case, less of wisdom and folly* - important, that the answers are true.
Not assuming for a moment version of the accident, let's see if would be someone, who rejoice with this tragedy?
Can it be useful to anyone for anything immediate disappearance from public life several dozen group of people deciding on key issues Polish - defense, financial policy, national memory, etc.? Who could have in this business? Polish people, Polish patriots, or perhaps those to whom the existence of Polish bother?
If they want eliminate from the political life of large amounts of people uncomfortable at the same time, located at the same time on a small area, away from the possibility of quickly provide effective relief, whether it would be best not to do it in an aircraft?
Is it normal that the plane that crashed was under Russian control of the technical and passed the last review in Samara (Russia)? Is the safety of heads of state, Polish political elites should be at the time of stay in the air in the hands of Russian technicians?
Whether Russian special services, if they want, would have the technical ability to share organizing attacks, or may not be able to do something like this, to plan and execute? In which territory would be easier to organize such an action, only to fully control it (avoid the press, placing a land militia, not to grant interviews, etc.) - for another, or on your own?
If somebody wants to cripple, incapacitate an organized community, the State, which group will be eliminate first, the social? Ordinary gray citizens who may, at most, to vote in elections once every few years or maybe those who every day take many decisions, which determine the fate of the whole community? And who, during the Second World War the Germans and the Soviets murdered and deported to concentration camps in the first place, or sometimes not officers, professors, clergy, people in power? Are not those his authority, in word and attitude have an impact on the entire nation, would be able to pull it towards independence? If I want to kill somebody, then cut his arm, heel, or maybe your head? Has anyone heard of the so-called cutting of heads of the nation (Germany did it in Auschwitz, Dachau, Stutthof, and the Soviets at Katyn, Kharkov, Mednove etc.)?
I think it wasn’t the case. First you need to ask yourself:
For what kind of Kaczynski hasn’t been invited on the same day as the Tusk? Why Putin wanted to split them?
It certainly wasn’t the case. How is it possible that the pilot, 2km from the airport was at the height of the trees!? It was the fog (and it's not so big), Polish plane full of VIPs.... and someone took advantage of the opportunity. Pilot landed just as he gave to the airport. Apparently, the light from the runway where set in the woods. The stories of witnesses shows that the pilot trying to pick up yet. So when he was low enough to see, that it wasn’t the airport (gave wrong parameters) tried to salvage the situation. Unfortunately ... I also heard from witness, that he heard two explosions - one lesser, second greater-could also be the case that the pilot realized that there isn’t the landing and try to escape, but the Russians shot yet down because it would be stupidity releasing them) And now all deal with the Russian service nobody commit to the scene. Isn’t it strange? They have a “black box” and they can do what they want. And probably it will be the pilot foult, because he can’t no longer defend himself... not the man who advise him.
I think it was attempt, why they don’t let the Polish jurnalists immediatly after the split. Why they put gun to jurnalists head, why nobody speak about it no longer, why similar threads are removed from the forums? I wasn’t supporter of L. Kaczynski, but he was patriot, who spoke the truth about Russia, and took a penalty, for which was he awarded in Georgia as a national hero! International news talked about the accident based on the Russian media and knowing, that the investigation is also Russian. Russia depends on the fact that the mob thought it was an accident, and Poland is too weak to say anything or accuse Russia.
As for me, too much cases here.
In april, when it happened, my first thought was that it was all planned by FSB or other Russian services, and it may be a start of next war. Now I think more about real accident, cause we don't see war coming :} One is a fact for me, we never going to know what really happened there.
ReplyDeleteIn this case, there are many unexplained issues. Many of them probably never come out. In my opinion, the Russians wanted to get rid of the people in our government that most disturb their business. This disaster for the Russians was the best chance to erase all traces. In addition, the Russians know that they are powerful and we can not declare war on them even when the truth will come out. I think it was a coup.
ReplyDeleteI think that the truth will come to light until many years after Putin's death, and if Russia won't be so strong that all fears them. Now there has been no outbreak of the war, because everyone is afraid to prove guilt Russians and the world believes what they say.
ReplyDeleteQuestionable is also the fact that the Russian, who recorded this video after returning home he died ...
I agree with Ernest. For sure we won't get true information now... Propably it was accident but plains are so safe right now. How could it happen that special plain, with special pilots and crew could fall down?
ReplyDeleteI don't agree with theory that some mysterious, super secret organization or simply the Russians institutions like KGB, FSB, GRU or another made this accident happened. Don't take me wrong, I like conspiracy theories, but in this case I thin it was just old used aeroplane, bed weather conditions and wrong decisions made.
ReplyDeleteI'm not believer of conspiracy theories but I just want to remind one plane crash connected with Polish politician - Wladyslaw Sikorski. It occurred in 1943 and we still don't know the answer if it was the reason of technical problems or some other... It's worth to mention that it happened just after Sikorski had requested IRC to investigate the issue of Katyn's mass murder. Maybe that's the way the Russians used to deal with Katyn's problem...
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion it was an accident but what amazes me is that so many important people flew in one plane. It was not only an easy target for terrorists but everybody should know that accidents happen. Therefore it was not only the pilots fault.
ReplyDeleteMaybe that isn't good, but I don't want to talk about this topic. It's just to political.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, there was and is too much of speculating based on hatred of the ruling party towards the Russian people and their government. Most of the ideas explaining that this accident was an assassination sound like taken from a cheap American sensational movie. However, I think it would be best for me not to elaborate on my view, it seems to awake strong emotions in people around, so I do not want to hurt or discourage anyone by expressing my true opinion.
ReplyDeleteThere is many websites where we can find different explanations of this accident. Many people believes it was Russian murder. I also. Our government ignores Smolensk's case. They believes in what Russian people say. It's not normal because many important polish people were killed but our government is doing nothing to know what it's the true.
ReplyDeletePersonally, I really want to believe that it was an accident - a chain of tragic mistakes and inadvertences. I hope that Russian side makes whole investigation difficult just becouse they don't want to admit their faults connected with plane construction or airport service.
ReplyDeleteI'm not a biggest fan of Jarosław Kaczyński but I agree that investigation is too slow and inefficient - I'm writing this comment in December and nothing changed since this entry was posted there's almost no progress. I hope that will change in the incoming year.